Why Us
What We Offer
Choose All-Star Cookies & Creamery for a unique cookie and ice cream experience. Our cookies are lovingly crafted using the finest ingredients, ensuring every bite is a moment of pure delight.
Daily Handcrafted and Freshly Baked
Cookies
We make our cookies daily to ensure the highest quality. Nothing is better than a fresh-baked, warm cookie!
Bluebell's Best
Ice Cream
Nothing goes better with a warm cookie than sweet and creamy ice cream. Take your treat to the next level with an ice cream cookie sandwich!
Elevate Your Event
Cookie Cakes &
Custom Orders
We are happy to customize any bulk orders with advance notice of 24 hours for holiday parties, birthday parties, office parties, or any other "just because"!
Let Us Sweeten Your Next Event!
From full-service cookie catering and on-site event booths to custom-made cookie cakes and decorated iced cookies, we offer a variety of ways to make any gathering sweeter. Whether you’re planning a corporate event, hosting a community celebration, or marking a special occasion or holiday, our gourmet cookies are crafted to delight every guest and every moment.
About Us
Our Story
At All-Star Cookies and Creamery, we believe in the magic of baking. Our journey began with a passion for creating mouthwatering cookies that bring joy to every bite. Shane Freels and Angela Thurmond saw an opportunity to bring this iconic building back to life. It was once the home of Sammye's Candy and Shane, growing up in Stephenville, has fond memories of visiting when he was a child and checking out baseball cards and candy in one place. Angela loves creating and this seemed like a great fit. They wanted to create an inviting atmosphere for people to make a fun memory of getting a sweet treat with friends and family. "We love sports and sweets, so combining the two seemed like a natural fit!"
Contact
Have a question or feedback? Reach out to us, and we'll be happy to assist you.
